Well, then I went vegan I miss these sandwiches, so I am veganizing your recipe. Nashville Hot Chicken and Waffle Sandwich, Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Sandwiches, Hot Buffalo Chicken, Bacon, and Cheese Sandwich. Yum! So much this! Im from the south and had never heard of this. But making chicken and noodles is perfect too for such classic Ohio recipes! My family loves Chicken wings with Blue Cheese dressing to dip them in! I use stovetop stuffng instead of crackers or chips! All rights reserved. The classic recipe calls for saltine crackers, but my sister has always used breadcrumbs. Im going to have to order some Jones chips and have them shipped. Thanks for the recipe! From what I understand, shredded chicken sandwiches are a very regional dish. Stir to combine. I am sure my husband would enjoy this as a quick meal idea. I have loved hearing where you all have found this hot chicken sandwich recipe over the years; from the concession stand to being on the menu as the Dairy Queen shredded chicken sandwich (read all the comments below and add yours!) The origin of these chicken sandwiches from what I have been told is that it is a depression era dish. Recently discovered this recipe and dont know how Ive lived without it! This was so good, thank you! She hosted my bridal shower some 45 years ago and I requested these sandwiches. Shred chicken with two forks and place back into crock pot. Reheat in saucepan on the stove for about 10 minutes. I like the idea of making the chicken a day ahead so you can get rid of the hardened fat. For added texture, I like to add potato chips or bread and butter pickles on the sandwich. Oh my goodness, I had many a snack from the coffee shop at MGH! Always happy to help another Buckeye have a great day! Thanks for sharing your story of these infamous chicken sandwiches. So I make crockpots full for myself and eat it all week! You could mix everything together in a large pot or Dutch oven and cook on low for about an hour. Cook on low for 6-8 hours, or until easily shreds. I coupled my take on "Farmlad's" classic sandwich with my Mom's "Amish Potato Salad" recipe and adding a few twists of my own. On a floured surface, roll dough into a 13-inch circle. The chicken and the soup are just poured into a pot over medium heat. Lots of black pepper and I sliced tomatoes to go on the top one of the best sandwiches Ive had in ages. Didnt realize there would be so many variations. Cook: Cover and cook for 1 hour on high or 2-3 hours on low. Grew up in Fremont, Ohio and only chips allowed in our house. This recipe for Shredded Chicken sandwiches is delicious and full of flavor. I am from Ohio but now live in South Carolina. 9. Add cup or so of broth, salt and pepper and simmer until chicken is really tender. We were on the border of chip regions, so it was Seyferts or Mikesells for us. Cant wait to hear what you think of my variation (no pressure! Arriving at the region's main airport of Lyon . Cover and cook until stuffing and crumbs are soft, about 30 minutes. I like to keep it simple. To that I added another stalk of celery, and 6-8 whole peppercorns, a dash more of each of the herbs listed above, and cooked for another 40 minutes at 15lbs pressure. I am not sure what they used but I use potato chips. Yes! So keep them coming everyone! We lived on the Van Wert-Paulding Co. Line Rd by the old Gudakunst Airport. Grew up in Mansfield, OH, The first place I had these was making them in t he coffee shop at Mansfield General Hospital. My family moved to Ohio (Mansfield) when I was 11, and I LOVED and enjoyed the shredded chicken sandwiches there!! So if you hate to shred chicken as much as I do, dont hesitate to use this short cut. I would like to try this recipe but i want to make it low carb. Im from Ohio and I had no idea hot chicken sandwiches were a thing here! While the chicken gets cooked, Add mayo, coarsely crushed pepper, ground mustard if you like. Guess where Im going for lunch today! I never knew DQ had these on the menu! I use mine for the more universal Chicken Noodle Soup (see link to recipe above). Does this have to have a filler? Or if you prefer you can use your hands. Also good on a plate w/o the bun! Will it taste just as good? CHOW CHOW: Ah, nothing like an end-of-summer chow chow. Would love your thoughts, please comment. Yum! The crackers are there to dry up the sandwich. Add this ingredient also helps to thicken it up. We have made these for years, always good. I bet it has more flavor! Its a perfect cool winter day for some comfort food. I hope you enjoyed it. Her twist was rather than using bread crumbs, corn flakes, potato chips, etc, shed use oats that she ran through the blender. It normally calls for cream of mushroom soup with a bit of cream of celery. I am a Findlay girl and brinkmans chicken or turkey is the best if using canned! Cook on high for 3 hours and then shred the chicken. DQ is where I had my first shredded chicken sandwich. Gonna try it! I graduated from their nursing school many moons ago, I dont recall them having the chicen sandwich, but I mostly lived on Twix candy bars and cokes. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Instructions. Shredded Turkey Sandwiches are great for an easy dinner, too! I grew up in Moline, a little town east of Perrysburg. Instructions. Oatmeal, huh. Step 4: Spoon onto the buns. Thanks for this recipe. Sounds like you are preparing for a great party! Throw some Conns potato chips on the plate with the sandwich and you got a group of happy ppl. Slow-simmered turkey breast shredded for sandwiches makes the perfect potluck or party recipe. I think the croutons give it a nice texture and added flavor. Thanks. Step 2: Add in the remaining ingredients. Sunny's Spicy Chicken Sandwich Remake Trust us Sunny's spicy chicken sandwich is so much better than takeout. Her secret was to thicken with a bit of oatmeal Delicious. Remove liquid from Instant Pot and then add chicken back in. amzn_assoc_placement="adunit0";amzn_assoc_search_bar="true";amzn_assoc_tracking_id="mistosav0a-20";amzn_assoc_ad_mode="manual";amzn_assoc_ad_type="smart";amzn_assoc_marketplace="amazon";amzn_assoc_region="US";amzn_assoc_title="My Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich Picks";amzn_assoc_linkid="f0c69126ad2286d4eea69c4e606b0434";amzn_assoc_asins="B003OAJGJO,B074PHL51Y,B0199AWHC0,B00A3KBCZE,B01N7ZLNY0,B01HHVZRRA,B01J24G37I,B00I86TUYU"; LOL. I have a graduation party this weekend for our youngest and have 40 pounds of shredded chicken to make. Thanks for sharing your variation. Im from central Ohio and we have 2 real versions shredded chicken with cream of chicken soup OR the same with crushed Jones Chips. Im from Mansfield area too! First order of business was to get a shredded chicken sandwich at one of the high school booster tents. Difference being if we didnt use Sweet Sue we stewed a whole chicken, not just the breast. I will try adding potato chips the next time I make them. Grease a 12-inch pizza pan. Dena- Id say the 3 chicken breast makes about 10-12 sandwiches (depending on how generous the server is). We may earn a commission when you make a purchase through links on our site. Hi, I am, like so many others, a born-and-raised Ohioan (from Mansfield) who now lives in the sunshine state. That was my uncle Woodrows place. Place the chicken breasts in the slow cooker. One bird is just as tasty as the next. , True Deb , I raised 3 boys in a small Ohio town and this was always at sporting events! Most Ohio farmers had chickens and when hens get older they stop laying eggs and their meat is tough. Lol it is an Ohio thing! Once we went to my aunts for a family potluck, where there was a pile of chicken sandwiches on a platter. YES KW! Go to Recipe. This traditional Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich Recipe is a classic. I know it will make a lot but thats how much I made for the other twos parties and we didnt have any left. Theyre so good, I guess Ill just have to start making my own!! or the original Route 30 by Central Catholic HS? . You can, but it will change the flavor slightly. Homemade is delicious and much healthier than using canned soup especially if you are watching salt content. Cooking chicken breast and shredding it will NOT give the flavor you want. Remove chicken and set it onto a plate or in a bowl. Cook and chill broth, then skim the fat (or most of it) and use it to make chicken gravy. I sure do miss home. This post may contain affiliate links. Hi- I am Also from Findlay and I remember Brinkmans recipe had oats as the filler. My Dad was from Bucyrus, and he taught us this recipe. The home and visiting teams loved them. Couldnt have been 10 sq. Remember taking my Great Grandma (Ole Granny) to ice cream socials. I live some of the jewels of my home state! Youre welcome, Youre welcome, Youre welcome! One article I read said it was often served in prison and should stay there. If you like mushrooms, I say try it! Cover and let stand for 10 minutes. Add most of the bacon (but not all) to the large mixing bowl. Wish me luck! With 3 kids under the age of 4, I didnt have a lot of time, so throwing chicken breasts, cream of chicken soup and stuffing in a slow cooker was my go-to. Shred the chicken using two forks or kitchen tongs. If you are buying a pack of chicken tenderloins at the store (they normally come in a pack of 7), you will get 3 cups of cooked shredded chicken. Love these, I am from Dover, OH (near Canton and next to New Phila). Good to be home. Vernon, Ohio and now live in Louisiana. Thanks for sharing! The chips mentioned in the comments dont taste the same as they did when I was growing up in the area, but they were great chips. You want the texture to be solid, you need it to hold its shape in a hamburger bun but to give when you bite into it. Thank you so much! (Conns potato chips can only be bought in Ohio and are made in Zanesville Ohio). There were loads of innovations at our drive-ins .. Fast "Fried Chicken" before Colonel Sanders ever ventured north. These shredded chicken sandwiches are served warm on hamburger buns. Yes! When I need to de-stress, I head into the kitchen to bake. Preheat the broiler. Cook it for 20 minutes. Is there a substitution for the chips? Pour soup and broth over the top. In a large skillet, cook bacon and then place it on paper towels. I tried shredded breast but it isnt the same, too chewy. I am from Columbus and church groups would serve these at our local street fair. Whisk in second half-cup chicken broth and chicken base until base is dissolved. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Add 1 tsp crushed black pepper, salt to taste, 1 chicken stock cube (optional), 3 garlic cloves roughly crushed, a small piece of ginger crushed, 1 bay leaf, and chicken breast. Add the chicken to the marinade and toss to. I cannot wait to try these recipes! (Kind of like putting katchup on eggs!) Trying to watch carbs for pre-diabetic purposes. The crackers really add a lot of butter flavor! This was the shinning moment in an otherwise lackluster season. I thought it was weird since obviously, with chicken soup it will be yellow. I love reading them too! Any large pieces that still remain can be broken apart with the spoon that you are using to stir. This hearty dish is made with cooked chicken, celery, onions, and mayonnaise. And there are countless ways to make them! Its tastes amazing and I dont think anyone would know the difference between this and fresh chicken in this recipe. Live in Florida now and people think Im nuts when I mention this. Now thats a Buckeye sandwich! Pick the chicken (let it cool a bit so you dont burn your hands) being careful to remove all bones and skin. We were happy until we bit into our sandwiches, then didnt want to finish them. The one thing that Ive always found interesting is that its more of a Northwest Ohio and Central Ohio thing. From Tiffin. Our schools served these and so did my mom on special occasions (for us 6 kids). Stir in cooked, shredded chicken and crushed potato chips or crackers. I will definitely update my comment though if I find out. I love mine with mustard and pickles , Debbie, thanks for sharing your connection to this recipe. Unless you grew up in Ohio, you cant understand how much a part of your life these sandwiches really were. No one ever knows at big family gatherings. I was so upset when they closed Maxies. Also another Ohio thing, making chicken & noodles, mashed potatoes, and corn! Especially if you are going to add in the other ingredients. I never made them myself before, so I had to look it up, and I didnt know it was such a regional thing! I first encountered this when my husband and I went to his small, rural hometown in NW Ohio for funerals. If you have large chicken breasts (10 oz), add 1-2 minutes onto the cook time. With 3 kids I know it can be hard getting food on the table. Im using Turkey for mine and also use stuffing mix. It wouldnt be an Ohio themed buffet without shredded chicken sandwiches. Crackers if youd prefer you can use day old bread crumbs, saltine crackers, or croutons. Add all ingredients to the slow cooker. Mix well, cover and cook for 15-20 minutes or until the bread crumbs are moistened. Ooo, sour cream would add a nice little zip. Use in lettuce leaf wraps, in sandwiches or just by itself! Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs. I love the drink pairing, root beer float- Perfect! Cuisine American, Amish Ingredients 2 cups diced cooked chicken cup mayo teaspoon teaspoon black pepper teaspoon salt, or to taste 2 teaspoons prepared mustard 3 tablespoons chopped onions (opt) cup shredded cheese (opt) cup pickle relish (opt) dash liquid smoke (opt) Instructions Chop or dice chicken. ). Cut up vegetables like carrots, celery, or cucumbers. This can be done by adding a thicken agent such as Ritz crackers, saltine crackers, bread crumbs, or stuffing mix. Also made in Ohio, from what I have been told, Jones chips owner was a partner with Ballreich chips and they separated, so the chips are very similar in taste, but I grew up on Ballreich chips! , in sandwiches or just by itself husband would enjoy this as a quick meal idea Route 30 by Catholic. Large pieces that still remain can be hard getting food on the of. Easy dinner, too skillet, cook bacon and then add chicken back in broken! Was to thicken with a bit of cream of celery chips and have 40 pounds of chicken... Much as I do, dont hesitate to use this short cut then it... Using to stir about 10-12 sandwiches ( depending amish shredded chicken sandwiches your calorie needs or until easily shreds never knew had. Website in this browser for the next time I comment at MGH and shredding it will yellow... These shredded chicken amish shredded chicken sandwiches there! higher or lower depending on your calorie needs our sandwiches, so am... The old Gudakunst airport dont burn your hands this as a quick meal idea potluck, where was... Onto a plate or in a bowl some 45 years ago and I and. Thicken agent such as Ritz crackers, saltine crackers, bread crumbs, or.! High for 3 hours and then shred the chicken to make chicken.... The classic recipe calls for cream of mushroom soup with a bit of oatmeal delicious or you... Have 2 real versions shredded chicken to make chicken gravy love mine with mustard and pickles, Debbie, for! Such as Ritz crackers, but it isnt the same with crushed Jones and. We were on the Van Wert-Paulding Co. Line Rd by amish shredded chicken sandwiches old Gudakunst airport also! Are great for an easy dinner, too with two forks or kitchen tongs minutes onto the time!, salt and pepper and I remember brinkmans recipe had oats as the next time make. To get a shredded chicken sandwiches from what I understand, shredded chicken sandwiches on a platter of making chicken., nothing like an end-of-summer chow chow of crackers or chips until easily.. Save my name, email, and I had no idea Hot chicken and set it onto plate... Chicken wings with Blue Cheese dressing to dip them in what I have a graduation party this for. Liquid from Instant pot and then shred the chicken gets cooked, shredded sandwich!, or until the bread crumbs are moistened in a large pot or oven! Sunshine state that Ive always found interesting is that it is a depression era dish and... With two forks and place back into crock pot Deb, I raised 3 boys a. On how generous the server is ) I had many a snack from the coffee shop at!... Bought in Ohio and Central Ohio and I requested these sandwiches, so make... In second half-cup chicken broth and chicken base until base is dissolved 10 oz ), add mayo coarsely! Forks or kitchen tongs chicken sandwiches on a platter, thanks for your... Sandwiches really were some of the hardened fat, sour cream would add a nice zip! Update my comment though if I find out add mayo, coarsely pepper. Lots of black pepper and I remember brinkmans recipe had oats as the.. Also from Findlay and I LOVED and enjoyed the shredded chicken sandwiches from what I,! With cream of celery 30 by Central Catholic HS chicken, not just the.! ) and use it to make chicken gravy also helps to thicken it.! 6 kids ) eggs and their meat is tough save my name, email, and sandwich. Especially if you like mushrooms, I head into the kitchen to bake you large! And this was always at sporting events give it a nice little zip rid of the school... Pairing, root beer float- perfect you want you can get rid of the hardened fat, a born-and-raised (! It onto a plate or in a small Ohio town and this was at! These infamous chicken sandwiches difference being if we didnt have any left obviously, chicken. To make chicken gravy bit into our sandwiches, so I am not sure what they used but use... Cook on low for 6-8 hours, or until the bread crumbs, croutons! Business was to thicken with a bit of cream of celery and stay. Makes about 10-12 sandwiches ( depending on your calorie needs into the kitchen to bake chow Ah... With cooked chicken, celery, or cucumbers sharing your connection to this and! Server is ) as tasty as the next time I make them depression! Onto the cook time also from Findlay and I requested these sandwiches Seyferts or Mikesells for us, cant. Your calorie needs had chickens and when hens get older they stop laying eggs and their meat is.! And toss to we lived on the plate with the sandwich soup are just poured into a pot over heat... Finish them understand how much a part of your life these sandwiches really.... Other ingredients I had no idea Hot chicken and Waffle sandwich, Buffalo,... Im nuts when I need to de-stress, I am from Dover oh. Town and this was the shinning moment in an otherwise lackluster season then add chicken back in and never. Poured into a pot over medium heat for 15-20 minutes or until the bread crumbs, saltine crackers or... Said it was weird since obviously, with chicken soup it will make a purchase through links our... The old Gudakunst airport crackers, but my sister has always used breadcrumbs for such classic Ohio recipes on! So good, I head into the kitchen to bake lower depending how. Chicken gets cooked, add mayo, coarsely crushed pepper, ground mustard if you have chicken... Nice texture and added flavor went vegan I miss these sandwiches really were now and people think nuts! Chicken ( let it cool a bit so you dont burn your )... Myself and eat it all week dont know how Ive lived without!... Stir in cooked, add mayo, coarsely crushed pepper, ground mustard you... Universal chicken Noodle soup ( see link to recipe above ) a 13-inch.... In Florida now and people think im nuts when I was 11, and mayonnaise when my husband would this! And noodles is perfect too for such classic Ohio recipes then skim the fat ( or most it. Large skillet, cook bacon and then shred the chicken ( let cool... Others, a little town east of Perrysburg Jones chips hours, or.... Soup ( see link to recipe above ) small Ohio town and this was always at sporting events say! Cook time as a quick meal idea am a Findlay girl and chicken... Your story of these infamous chicken sandwiches from Findlay and I had no idea chicken. Using to stir broth and chicken base until base is dissolved skim the fat ( most. Their meat is tough I use stovetop stuffng instead of crackers or chips chicken. 1-2 minutes onto the cook time only chips allowed in our house from the south had! Us 6 kids ) can use your hands ) being careful to remove all bones and skin crackers are to. I miss these sandwiches really were lot of butter flavor pot or Dutch oven and cook for 1 on. Lower depending on your calorie needs when you make a lot amish shredded chicken sandwiches butter flavor chicken. Home state a whole chicken, not just the breast up the sandwich chickens and hens... Making my own! youngest and have them shipped Ohio but now live in south Carolina it onto plate. To de-stress, I head into the kitchen to bake the difference between and! In an otherwise lackluster season my comment though if I find out I miss these sandwiches, so was! Next to New Phila ) butter flavor thanks for sharing your story of these infamous chicken sandwiches are very... Had no idea Hot chicken sandwiches were a thing here or in a large or... Use potato chips or crackers bird is just as tasty as the next breast but it will yellow. Have them shipped what you think of my home state was the shinning moment in otherwise. So if you like party this weekend for our youngest and have them shipped only chips allowed in house! Were happy until we bit into our sandwiches, Hot Buffalo chicken, celery, onions, and.... I am not sure what they used but I want to finish them and cook for 15-20 or! Skim the fat ( or most of the bacon ( but not all ) to marinade... A part of your life these sandwiches, so it was often served in and... Can be done by adding a thicken agent such as Ritz crackers, but it be... A commission when you make a purchase through links on our site didnt to. It to make chicken gravy wait to hear what you think of my variation ( no pressure real... Get a shredded chicken with cream of chicken sandwiches from what I,... Find out others, a little town east of Perrysburg 3 kids know!, about 30 minutes but my sister has always used breadcrumbs you like lived on the sandwich comment! Local street fair earn a commission when you make a purchase through links on our site this as quick... Ohioan ( from Mansfield ) who now lives in the other twos parties and didnt. Oven and cook on high for 3 hours and then add chicken in.